Many people who find themselves charged with a crime – especially for the first time – assume that law enforcement officers and others involved with their case know what they’re doing and have followed the required procedures. However, there are many things that can go wrong when handling a case – either intentionally or unintentionally – that can compromise a defendant’s rights.
One of these is failure to maintain a proper “chain of custody” for evidence. Just what does that mean?
How can a chain of custody be broken?
Any piece of evidence must be properly handled from the time it’s seized or otherwise collected until it is used in court. Law enforcement officers, lab technicians, prosecutors and anyone else who handles a piece of evidence must follow strict protocols to ensure that it’s not compromised in any way. If it is, that’s often referred to as a “broken” or “breached” chain of custody.
If the chain of custody is broken, there is a chance that the evidence was compromised or contaminated. Even if there’s a very small chance that this occurred, that evidence can’t be used to try to convict someone of a crime. This can include anything from DNA evidence and fingerprints to drugs, weapons, flash drives and more. Below are a few examples of a break in the chain of custody:
- Crime scene contamination: For example, if a crime scene wasn’t properly cordoned off, an authorized person could have accessed it and contaminated or even planted evidence.
- Improper handling of evidence: For example, a law enforcement officer might touch one or more pieces of evidence without gloves or not change their gloves when moving from one area to another.
- Improper evidence storage: Evidence must be stored in approved, tamper-proof packaging in a secured facility, and anyone who “checks out” evidence for any reason must sign for it.
When evidence has to be moved and handled by multiple people (for example, if it is sent to a lab for testing), that provides additional chances for the chain of custody to be broken and for the evidence to be lost or contaminated.
Chain of custody is the kind of thing that an experienced criminal defense attorney can investigate as they explore all possible options for a client. That’s one reason that getting legal guidance as early as possible can be critical for someone whose future could be compromised as a result of an unfavorable resolution to a criminal defense concern.
